All WNY Team Small School 2023
- First Team - Audrey Grable '24
- Second Team - Isabella DeMarzio '24 and Reese McCrea '24
All Catholic Team 2023
- Isabella DeMarzio '24
- Audrey Grable '24
- Reese McCrea '24
All WNY Team Small School 2022
- First Team - Audrey Grable '24
All Catholic Team 2022
- First Team - Audrey Grable '24 and Isabella DeMarzio '24
- Second Team - Carly Allen '25
All WNY Team 2021
All Catholic Team 2021
- First Team - Isabella Allen '22 and Audrey Grable '24
- Second Team - Blair Kuzniarek '22
All Catholic Team Fall 2 - 2021
- First Team - Isabella Allen '22 and Audrey Grable '24
All Catholic Team 2019
- First Team - Siobhan Ryan '20 and Hannah Tudor '20
- Second Team - Isabella Allen '22
All WNY Team 2019
- First Team Small School - Siobhan Ryan '20
- Second Team Small School - Hannah Tudor '20 & Isabella Allen ‘22
Recent Championships
Varsity: Playoff runner-up 2018, 2017, 2016
Varsity: MMHSAA Champions in 1998, 2002, 2009, and 2010
Varsity: Catholic State Participants in 2002, 2003, 2005, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010