All Catholic Team 2023
All Catholic Team 2022
- First Team - Greta Bair '23 and Rylee Chamberlain '23
- Second Team - Mariah Huss '23 and Anna Ratchuk '25
All Catholic Team 2021
- First Team - Greta Bair '23 and Mariah Huss '23
- Second Team - Olivia Kurdziel '22 and Ellie Parkes '22
All Catholic Team 2020
- First Team - Greta Bair '23
All WNY Team 2019
- Honorable Mention - Rory Schaeffer '20
All Catholic Team 2019
- First Team - Ella Mazzara '20 and Rory Schaeffer '20
- Second Team - Greta Bair '23
Recent MMHSAA Championships
2015, 2014, 2012